Skip to Content

Forensic Accounting in New Jersey Divorce Cases: How Financial Analysis Supports Asset Clarity

By Jay Mota,  MAFF, CVA, CDFA, CFP®, CQS, ChFC, WMCP
January 16, 2026 by
Forensic Accounting in New Jersey Divorce Cases: How Financial Analysis Supports Asset Clarity
Jay

In New Jersey, divorce means dividing everything that got built up during the marriage. That sounds straightforward until you realize one spouse handled all the finances, or owns a business, or has income that seems to shift depending on what's convenient. 

When the money picture isn't clear, you can't divide things fairly. That's where a forensic accountant divorce specialist comes in.

I've worked on a lot of these cases in New Jersey. The spouse who didn't manage the money often walks in feeling like they're at a disadvantage. 

They don't know what accounts exist. They don't understand how the business is valued. They're not sure if the income being reported is the whole story. My job is to figure that out.


What a Forensic Accountant
Actually Does in a Divorce


People hear "forensic accountant" and picture someone in a crime drama tracking down stolen millions. The reality is less dramatic but just as important. In divorce, forensic accounting means going through financial records to see what's really there.

That includes looking at bank statements, tax returns, credit card records, business financials, loan applications, retirement accounts, and anything else that shows where money came from and where it went. 

We're looking for the full picture. Sometimes that picture matches what's being disclosed. Sometimes it doesn't.

In New Jersey divorces, the court uses equitable distribution. That doesn't necessarily mean 50/50. It means fair, based on a bunch of factors. 

But "fair" only works if everyone's working from accurate numbers. If assets are hidden or income is understated, the division can't be equitable. It's built on bad information.


How Financial Inconsistencies Get Uncovered

Financial Inconsistencies in Divorce Cases

 

There's no single trick to finding hidden money. It's usually a combination of things that don't line up.

  • Lifestyle versus reported income. Someone says they earn $120,000 a year, but they're driving a new BMW, taking vacations to Europe, and paying private school tuition for two kids. That math doesn't work. Either income is higher than reported, or money is coming from somewhere that wasn't disclosed.

  • Business irregularities. Business owners have more ways to move money around. Cash payments that don't hit the books. Personal expenses written off as business costs. Salaries paid to family members who don't actually work there. Revenue that dips right before divorce papers get filed and mysteriously recovers afterward.

  • Unexplained transfers. Money that moves to accounts in someone else's name. "Loans" to friends or relatives. Large cash withdrawals without receipts. Overpaying the IRS one year to get a big refund the next, after the divorce is finalized.

I look at all of it. Bank records going back several years. Tax returns compared against what was actually deposited. Business profit-and-loss statements compared against the lifestyle. When things don't match, that's where we dig deeper.


New Jersey Specifics That Matter


New Jersey is an equitable distribution state, which means the court has discretion in how assets get divided, which may be viewed as fair but not necessarily equal.

Judges look at factors like the length of the marriage, each spouse's income and earning potential, contributions to marital property, and the standard of living during the marriage.

That last part matters a lot. If one spouse claims they can't afford much in support because business is slow, but the family has been living like business is great, the court needs to see that. Forensic analysis shows it.

New Jersey courts also have strong discovery rules. Both sides are supposed to disclose everything. But disclosure only works if someone's checking. A forensic accountant reviews what's been provided and identifies what's missing or doesn't add up.

Another thing I see often in New Jersey: business valuations that are all over the place. 

A spouse who owns a business might get it valued at one number for the divorce while using a completely different number for a loan application or insurance policy. We pull those records and compare.


Real Scenarios (Names Changed)


The contractor with cash income. A woman came to us because her husband, who ran a contracting business, claimed his income had dropped significantly the year they separated. She knew it didn't make sense because work had actually picked up. We reviewed bank deposits, job invoices, and compared against reported income. He'd been taking more payments in cash and not reporting them. That changed the support calculation significantly.

The executive with deferred compensation. A husband had stock options, restricted stock units, and deferred bonuses through his company. His wife knew he made good money, but didn't understand how much was tied up in these future payouts. We traced the compensation packages, valued what was marital versus separate, and built a clear picture. Without that, she would have walked away from assets she was entitled to.

The hidden account. A spouse found a credit card statement for an account she didn't know existed. That led us to a bank account that had never been disclosed. The account wasn't huge, but it raised questions about what else wasn't on the table. The answer turned out to be a brokerage account with six figures in it.


How This Supports Your Legal Team


Attorneys handle the legal strategy. We handle the financial analysis. When those two work together, the case is stronger.

We put together reports that attorneys can use in negotiations or present in court. We explain where the numbers came from, what doesn't match, and what it means for asset division. If things go to trial, we can testify as expert witnesses and stand behind our findings.

In mediation, having solid financials keeps the conversation grounded. It's harder to argue about money when there's a clear, documented picture of what exists.


When to Bring in a Forensic Accountant


Bring in a Forensic Accountant


Not every divorce needs forensic work. But if your spouse controlled the finances, owns a business, has income that fluctuates, or if you just feel like you're not seeing everything, it's worth a conversation.

The earlier you bring someone in, the better. We can guide the discovery process and make sure the right questions get asked up front. Waiting until after a settlement is signed makes everything harder.

If you're going through a high-asset divorce in New Jersey and the financial side feels unclear, Divorce Logic can help you get a real picture of what you're dealing with. That's the starting point for everything else.

Book a consultation and let's talk through your situation.

Talk with a Divorce Logic expert today!

How Property Is Divided in Divorce
By Jay Mota, MAFF, CVA, CDFA, CFP®, CQS, ChFC, WMCP